Category Archives: Advertising

“Hard Work” needs work…

The new TV campaign from Tangerine, formerly ING Direct, has all the right pieces but ignores one important element —humans have very short attention spans. One of the first things drilled into my head decades ago was that advertisers had less than 15 seconds to let consumers know what were selling. After that, they lose interest.

Today, we don’t even have that long to grab them.

In 2000, the average attention span was 12 seconds. Thanks to the proliferation of mobile digital devices and social media in our multi-screen world, research has discovered that the average attention span has now dropped to 8 seconds. According to the research study released last year by Microsoft, goldfish at 9 seconds have a longer attention span than we do.

What that translates to for advertisers is that waiting until the end of a commercial to reveal the brand, let alone the product or service category, is definitely not a good move. Unfortunately, that is what Tangerine has done with its new campaign.

The online bank has nailed its strategy, “You work hard for your money. Does your bank?” together with its “Forward Banking” tagline. This message is conveyed via a sequence of scenes of people hard at work in occupations such as health care, daycare and factory work. It’s all set to a terrific military-style cadence. The music is memorable and the visuals are well done but, to me, the spot suggested social programs, health care or labour unions. I tuned it out after a few seconds. It wasn’t until I read about the campaign launch in trade media that I took a second look and watched until the very end to find out that the ad was for a bank.

The agency behind the campaign may balk at the idea of superimposing the Tangerine logo on a corner of the screen or at least having one of the workers in the montage slip a cheque into their pocket at the end of a long day, but at least the viewer wouldn’t have to work so hard to get the message.

Stick to what you do best …

The potential purchase of Tim Hortons by Burger King could ultimately be a very good way for Tim Hortons to put its focus back on what it does best – coffee and donuts.

Tim Hortons has been straying from its core business for a while. It has had a limited menu of sandwiches and soups, which until now have fit well into the operation. Recently it has added breakfast sandwiches, questionable hash browns and with rumours of expansion into other items, Tim Hortons is dangerously close to no longer being considered a quick-serve restaurant.

We’re already seeing longer lines and longer wait times, both inside and drive-through, that will soon turn off even some diehard Timmies fans. Sticking to the core business is a lesson that McDonald’s learned in the 90s when it tested personal and family-sized pizza at some of its locations. Consumers really liked the product but not the 11 minutes prep time.

If the deal happens, both Tim Hortons and Burger King will hopefully continue to operate as two separate brands and concentrate on their individual core businesses. Burger King will get tax savings through the formation of a Canadian holding company and, because Burger King is an international brand, Timmies will get the opportunity to take the coffee and donuts that Canadians love to the world.

 

If it ain’t broke…

Earlier this summer Telus announced that following a review, it is ending its nearly 18-year relationship with Taxi and having The&Partnership take over as its creative AOR effective September 1. Advertising for subsidiary brand Koodo will be moving to a Vision 7 agency early in 2015. Taxi launched the Koodo brand for Telus in 2008.

It’s understandable that after such a long run a company might decide to reassess its marketing and advertising efforts or its agency – but to make a radical change to the look and feel of the advertising could be damaging to brand recognition and equity.

This is particularly true of the Telus and Koodo mobile brands. Advertising campaigns for both are distinctive and easily recognizable. Those are particularly important characteristics for advertising today in an age of texting, short sound bites and young people with the attention spans of a flea. Even 40 years ago, the rule of thumb for advertisers was that they maybe 12 to 15 seconds to capture consumer attention with their brands. Today they have about three seconds – if that.

The friendly, recognizable style we see in all the Telus print and TV advertising is as ideal for today’s consumers as it would be 18 years ago. Viewers just have to get a glimpse of the engaging animal or reptile actors shilling for Telus or a short peek at Koodo’s blue-hooded El Tabador cartoon mascot to identify the brands. Consumers that stick around for the end of the commercials or take a closer look at the print ads always find the messages or offers easy to find and understand.

Consistency and clarity. Perfect.